Providence Journal/Brown University Survey

October 21-22, 2000

Chafee Leads Weygand in U.S. Senate; Gore, Kennedy, and Langevin are Ahead of Opponents

A survey of 412 Rhode Island registered voters conducted October 21-22 also finds Vice President Al Gore with a lead over Texas Governor George W. Bush, and Providence Mayor Buddy Cianci with a 60 percent job performance rating (down from 75 percent last year). Voters support a referendum measure endorsing separation of powers in Rhode Island, but have doubts about state bonding for the proposed Heritage Harbor Museum.

PROVIDENCE, R.I. -- Senator Lincoln Chafee holds a lead over Congressman Robert Weygand in the race for U.S. Senate, according to a new Providence Journal/Brown University statewide survey. Al Gore, Patrick Kennedy and James Langevin are ahead in their respective races for presidency and Congress.

The survey was conducted October 21-22, 2000 at Brown University by Darrell M. West, director of the Taubman Center for Public Policy. It was based on a statewide random sample of 412 registered voters in Rhode Island. Overall, the poll had a margin of error of about plus or minus five percentage points. The survey was sponsored by the Providence Journal.

Among the 370 voters who indicated they are likely to vote in the November general election, 52 percent say they plan to vote for Chafee, 28 percent favor Weygand, 2 percent prefer Reform party candidate Christopher Young, 0 percent support independent candidate Kenneth Proulx, and 18 percent are undecided. Last August, 48 percent said they would support Chafee, 31 percent claimed they would vote for Weygand, 1 percent each favored Reform party candidate Christopher Young and independent candidate Kenneth Proulx, and 19 percent were unsure.

Demographic breakdowns reveal that Chafee runs well among Independents (besting Weygand by 55 to 24 percent) and is drawing 40 percent of the Democratic vote and 27 percent of non-whites. Chafee also leads Weygand among union members by 55 to 28 percent, among senior citizens by 46 to 31 percent. Forty-one percent say the fact that Lincoln Chafee is the son of former Senator John Chafee is important to their vote compared to 50 percent who believe it is not very important.

 

Chafee

Weygand

Young

Proulx

Gender

       

Male

57%

25%

2%

0%

Female

49

30

1

0

Party

       

Republican

82

11

0

0

Independent

55

24

3

0

Democrat

40

42

0

0

Race

       

White

54

27

1

0

Non-White

27

35

3

0

Union Member

       

Yes

55

28

0

0

No

52

28

2

0

Age

       

18-24

65

12

0

0

25-34

51

20

2

0

35-44

49

34

1

0

45-54

60

26

3

1

55-64

53

29

0

0

65+

46

31

2

0

City

       

Providence

40

38

1

0

East Bay

58

33

0

0

Newport

60

29

3

0

Blackstone Valley

49

21

4

1

Warwick/Cranston

62

18

2

0

South County

62

25

0

0

Western RI

53

27

0

0

In order to examine how voters saw the candidates, we asked them whether Chafee or Weygand would do a better job in several different areas. The results demonstrate that Chafee is seen as more likely to do a better job in areas from health care and foreign policy to education and keeping abortion legal. He furthermore is more likely to be seen as caring about people and being trusted to keep his word. By a 36 to 16 percent margin, more people are likely to blame Weygand than Chafee for the negative campaigning that has taken place in this race.

 

Chafee

Weygand

Improving health care

50%

25%

Handling foreign policy

48

20

Caring about people like you

49

27

Being trusted to keep word

50

20

Improving education

47

22

Keeping abortion legal

42

15

Responsibility for negative campaigning

16

36

Congressman Patrick Kennedy holds a lead of 59 to 24 percent over GOP challenger Steven Cabral among the 179 likely voters in the first district. In August, Kennedy led by 68 to 16 percent over Cabral. Kennedy runs better among women than men, earns 85 percent of the Democratic vote, and garners 64 percent of the union support.

 

Kennedy

Cabral

Gender

   

Male

56%

28%

Female

62

20

Party

   

Republican

13

65

Independent

53

32

Democrat

85

2

Race

   

White

58

25

Non-White

67

6

Union Member

   

Yes

64

27

No

58

23

Age

   

18-24

60

10

25-34

65

13

35-44

58

27

45-54

58

31

55-64

60

32

65+

58

19

City

   

Providence

73

16

East Bay

58

25

Newport

55

34

Blackstone Valley

55

21

In the second congressional district, among the 189 voters who indicated they were likely to vote in this race, Secretary of State James Langevin is favored by 54 percent, followed by 12 percent for independent candidate Rodney Driver, 7 percent for Republican Robert Tingle, and 2 percent for Green party candidate Dorman Hayes. Twenty-five percent are undecided.

Demographic breakdowns indicate that Langevin has a big margin (65 percent) among Democrats (compared to 7 percent for Driver, 2 percent for Tingle, and 4 percent for Hayes) and garners 56 percent of the Independent vote. He also gets 60 percent of the union vote, 50 percent of the non-white vote, and 48 percent of support among senior citizens.

 

Langevin

Driver

Tingle

Hayes

Gender

       

Male

52%

13%

10%

2%

Female

56

10

6

2

Party

       

Republican

32

14

27

0

Independent

56

13

5

2

Democrat

65

7

2

4

Race

       

White

55

13

6

2

Non-White

50

0

12

6

Union Member

       

Yes

60

8

8

5

No

53

13

7

1

Age

       

18-24

29

29

0

0

25-34

56

3

3

3

35-44

58

16

7

0

45-54

65

10

8

2

55-64

44

24

4

4

65+

48

14

5

2

City

       

Providence

59

9

4

4

Warwick/Cranston

62

7

11

0

South County

45

18

7

2

Western RI

40

13

13

0

In the presidential general election matchup, Gore garners support from 47 percent compared to 29 percent who say they will vote for Bush. Eight percent indicate they prefer Green party candidate Ralph Nader, one percent say they support Reform party nominee Pat Buchanan, and 15 percent are undecided. Last August, Gore was ahead of Bush by 54 to 23 percent, with 5 percent favoring Nader, 2 percent supporting Buchanan, and 16 percent unsure.

 

Bush

Gore

Nader

Buchanan

Gender

       

Male

37%

39%

7%

1%

Female

22

52

8

1

Party

       

Republican

87

7

2

0

Independent

32

39

10

0

Democrat

5

76

6

1

Race

       

White

31

45

8

1

Non-White

6

62

3

0

Union Member

       

Yes

27

48

7

3

No

29

47

8

1

Age

       

18-24

23

47

6

0

25-34

26

49

6

2

35-44

31

47

7

1

45-54

30

45

12

0

55-64

29

43

10

0

65+

28

49

5

2

City

       

Providence

18

59

9

1

East Bay

29

46

8

0

Newport

37

34

16

0

Blackstone Valley

24

41

6

1

Warwick/Cranston

29

58

4

2

South County

43

38

3

0

Western RI

47

27

13

7

By a 58 to 12 percent margin, likely voters support a call for a Constitutional Convention that would "expressly establish that Rhode Island government consists of separate and co-equal legislative, executive, and judicial branches similar to the governments established by the United States Constitution and by the Constitutions of all 49 other states." The measure is supported by most demographic categories, with the exception of non-whites, where only 27 percent say they support it.

Separation of Powers

Favor

Oppose

Gender

   

Male

66%

14%

Female

52

10

Party

   

Republican

60

7

Independent

63

12

Democrat

57

14

Race

   

White

62

11

Non-White

27

18

Union Member

   

Yes

60

18

No

58

11

Age

   

18-24

59

12

25-34

60

9

35-44

58

10

45-54

60

14

55-64

53

16

65+

58

11

City

   

Providence

53

15

East Bay

67

12

Newport

45

21

Blackston Valley

53

16

Warwick/Cranston

64

0

South County

73

5

Western RI

73

7

Forty-seven percent of likely voters oppose the state of Rhode Island issuing up to $25 million in bonds for the construction of the Heritage Harbor Museum, 32 percent are in favor, and 21 percent are undecided. Fifty-six percent of Republicans oppose the bond measured, compared to 51 percent of Independents, and 40 percent of Democrats.

Heritage Harbor Museum

Favor

Oppose

Gender

   

Male

35%

48%

Female

30

47

Party

   

Republican

27

56

Independent

30

51

Democrat

38

40

Race

   

White

33

48

Non-White

29

35

Union Member

   

Yes

37

47

No

32

48

Age

   

18-24

24

47

25-34

26

47

35-44

31

52

45-54

34

51

55-64

39

39

65+

33

46

City

   

Providence

37

46

East Bay

33

50

Newport

29

45

Blackston Valley

32

50

Warwick/Cranston

29

49

South County

23

52

Western RI

47

33

Sixty percent indicate that Providence Mayor Buddy Cianci is doing an excellent or good job as mayor of Providence, 16 percent rate him only fair, 10 percent say his performance is poor, and 14 percent are unsure. These numbers are down from a comparable statewide survey in February, 2000, when 70 percent gave Cianci excellent or good marks, 14 percent rated him only fair, 5 percent gave him poor marks, and 11 percent were undecided. In September, 1999, a statewide survey gave him a 75 percent excellent or good job performance rating.

In terms of demographic breakdowns, Cianci has a 74 percent job approval rating from union members, 57 percent among senior citizens, and 71 percent from those living in Providence.

Cianci Job

Excellent

Good

Only Fair

Poor

Gender

       

Male

26%

37%

14%

13%

Female

25

40

19

8

Party

       

Republican

26

39

15

6

Independent

22

40

19

11

Democrat

27

42

14

11

Race

       

White

25

39

17

10

Non-White

28

39

17

14

Union Member

       

Yes

33

41

11

11

No

24

39

18

10

Age

       

18-24

10

40

30

10

25-34

24

45

21

2

35-44

28

40

19

8

45-54

32

36

19

5

55-64

27

42

12

12

65+

21

36

12

20

City

       

Providence

30

41

15

10

East Bay

20

36

20

12

Newport

23

41

18

8

Blackstone Valley

28

37

15

10

Warwick/Cranston

23

28

23

8

South County

21

44

16

13

Western RI

27

40

20

7

Fifty-four percent say they believe Providence is headed in the right direction, 29 percent believe it has gotten off on the wrong track, and 17 percent did not offer an opinion. Statewide, older voters over the age of 55 were least likely to feel Providence is on the right track. Fifty-seven percent of those living in Providence believe the city is headed in the right direction.

Providence Direction

Right Track

Wrong Track

Gender

   

Male

54%

34%

Female

57

28

Party

   

Republican

56

26

Independent

55

33

Democrat

59

30

Race

   

White

57

31

Non-White

58

25

Union Member

   

Yes

59

29

No

57

31

Age

   

18-24

55

35

25-34

60

26

35-44

59

25

45-54

72

24

55-64

48

33

65+

47

40

City

   

Providence

57

34

East Bay

68

24

Newport

51

20

Blackstone Valley

59

30

Warwick/Cranston

45

38

South County

63

27

Western RI

53

33

In an open-ended question, we asked people what they thought the most important problem was facing the state and then classified answers into policy categories. The top issue named this month was health care (14 percent), followed by ethics and corruption (named by 13 percent of voters), education (13 percent,) and taxes (11 percent, up from 6 percent in August).

Most Important Problem, 2000

October

August

February

Health care

14%

20%

6%

Ethics/Corruption

13

15

11

Education

13

14

9

Taxes

11

6

13

Crime

3

5

2

Politicians and Govt

5

5

2

Jobs/Unemployment

4

3

10

Roads

3

1

1

Violence

2

2

1

Budget

2

1

1

We also looked at the impact of voter's views about the most important problem and whether the individual would vote for Chafee versus Weygand in the Senate race. Among those citing ethics and corruption, education, or taxes as the most important problem, Chafee holds a big lead over Weygand (56 to 30 percent on ethics and corruption, 60 to 27 percent on education, and 55 to 23 percent on taxes). However, with those feeling health care is the most important issue, voters are nearly evenly split in their candidate preferences. Forty percent indicate they would vote for Weygand, while 38 percent say they would prefer Chafee.

Most Important Problem

Would Vote for Chafee

Would Vote for Weygand

Health Care

38%

40%

Ethics/Corruption

56

30

Education

60

27

Taxes

55

23

For more information, contact Darrell M. West at (401) 863-1163 or see the website: www.InsidePolitics.org.

Survey Questions and Responses

(likely voters only) If the election for president were held today, would you vote for the Republican George W. Bush, Democrat Al Gore, Green Party candidate Ralph Nader, or Reform Party candidate Pat Buchanan? 29% Bush, 47% Gore, 8% Nader, 1% Buchanan, 15% don't know or no answer

(likely voters only) If the election for U.S. Senate were held today, would you vote for the Republican Lincoln Chafee, Democrat Robert Weygand, Reform party candidate Christopher Young, or independent candidate Kenneth Proulx? 52% Chafee, 28% Weygand, 2% Young, 0% Proulx, 18% don't know or no answer

(first congressional district likely voters only) If the election for U.S. Congress were held today, would you vote for the Republican Steven Cabral or Democrat Patrick Kennedy? 24% Cabral, 59% Kennedy, 17% don't know or no answer

(second congressional district likely voters only) If the election for second congressional district were held today, would you vote for the Republican Robert Tingle, Democrat James Langevin, independent candidate Rodney Driver, or Green party candidate Dorman Hayes? 7% Tingle, 54% Langevin, 12% Driver, 2% Hayes, 25% don't know or no answer

(likely voters only) In looking at the U.S. Senate candidates, which one would do a better job in the following areas:

a) improving health care: 50% Chafee, 25% Weygand, 1% Young, 0% Proulx, 24% don't know or no answer

b) handling foreign policy: 48% Chafee, 20% Weygand, 1% Young, 0% Proulx, 31% don't know or no answer

c) caring about people like you: 49% Chafee, 27% Weygand, 1% Young, 0% Proulx, 23% don't know or no answer

d) being trusted to keep his word: 50% Chafee, 20% Weygand, 0% Young, 0% Proulx, 30% don't know or no answer

e) improving education: 47% Chafee, 22% Weygand, 1% Young, 0% Proulx, 30% don't know or no answer

f) keeping abortion legal: 42% Chafee, 15% Weygand, 0% Young, 0% Proulx, 43% don't know or no answer

(likely voters only) Who do you think is more responsible for the negative campaigning that has taken place in this race? 16% Chafee, 36% Weygand, 0% Young, 0% Proulx, 48% don't know or no answer

As far as you are concerned, what is the most important problem facing the state of Rhode Island today? (open-ended answers coded as: 14% health care, 13% ethics and corruption, 13% education, 11% taxes, 5% politicians and government, 4% jobs/unemployment, 3% crime, 3% roads, 2% violence, 2% budget) (all others mentioned were under 2%)

How important to your vote is the fact that Lincoln Chafee is the son of former Senator John Chafee? 14% very important, 27% somewhat important, 50% not very important, 9% don't know or no answer

How would you rate the job Buddy Cianci is doing as Mayor of Providence? 24% excellent, 36% good, 16% only fair, 10% poor, 14% don't know or no answer

Generally speaking, would you say things in Providence are: 54% going in the right direction, 29% have they gotten off on the wrong track, 17% don't know or no answer

(likely voters only) Should a Constitutional Convention be called to expressly establish that Rhode Island government consists of separate and co-equal legislative, executive, and judicial branches similar to the governments established by the United States Constitution and by the Constitutions of all 49 other states? 58% Yes, 12% no, 30% don't know or no answer

(likely voters only) Do you favor or oppose the state of Rhode Island issuing up to $25 million in bonds for the construction of the Heritage Harbor Museum? 32% Favor, 47% oppose, 21% don't know or no answer