Taubman Survey on Providence Mayor's Election and Minority Relations

Providence Voters Favor Cicilline for Mayor; Minorities Feel They Have Too Little Power

A survey of 688 Providence voters conducted September 14 to 22 finds a big margin for David Cicilline over his general election rivals. Minorities, however, feel that they have too little political power in Providence.

PROVIDENCE, R.I. -- Democratic mayoral candidate David Cicilline holds a substantial lead over his general election opponents, according to a survey conducted by researchers at Brown University. The poll also inquired about people's views about minority relations, discrimination, and political power in Providence. Both African-Americans and Latino voters say that they have too little political power in the capital city.

The survey was conducted September 14 to 22, 2002 at Brown University by Darrell M. West, director of the Taubman Center for Public Policy and the John Hazen White, Sr. Public Opinion Laboratory, and Marion Orr, associate professor of political science, urban studies, and public policy. It is based on a citywide random sample of 688 residents. The poll was designed to measure candidate support in the general election and people's views about minority relations in Providence. Interviews were conducted either in English or Spanish, depending on whether there were non-English speakers in the household. Overall, the poll had a margin of error of about plus or minus four percentage points.

The survey was completed in conjunction with the Taubman Center's Thomas J. Anton/Frederick Lippitt conference "The Future of Providence" that will be held September 26-27. Mayor Martin O'Malley of Baltimore will deliver the keynote address at 7:30 p.m., Thursday, September 26 in Sayles Hall on the Campus Green. A panel of experts will discuss urban issues at 10:30 a.m., Friday, Sept. 27 in Sayles Hall and at noon that day in Sayles Hall, there will be a mayoral debate featuring David Cicilline, Greg Gerritt, Dave Talan, and Christopher Young. All conference events are free and open to the public.

In the race for mayor, 70 percent of the 506 likely general election voters say they plan to vote for Democrat Cicilline, 4 percent say they plan to vote for Republican Dave Talan, 2 percent favor Green party candidate Greg Gerritt, 1 percent support independent Christopher Young, and 23 percent are undecided. Cicilline's support is strong across racial lines. While 71 percent of whites say they favor him, he also draws support from 83 percent of African-Americans and 81 percent of Latino and Hispanic voters.

With Providence becoming a city that has a majority of minority residents, according to the U.S. Census, the survey asked a range of questions involving minority relations, especially between whites, African-Americans, and Latinos. Both African-American and Latino residents feel that they have too little political power in Providence. Seventy-seven percent of African-Americans feel they have too little power, while 57 percent of Latinos feel that way. Nine percent of whites feel that whites have too little political power in Providence.

Overall, 42 percent feel that opportunities for minorities are getting better, while 25 percent feel opportunities are staying the same, 13 percent believe they are getting worse, and 20 percent are undecided. However, minorities themselves are less optimistic. Among African-Americans, 36 percent say minority opportunities are getting better, while among Latinos, 42 percent feel opportunities are getting better. Forty-eight percent of whites feel minority opportunities are improving.

Twenty-three percent of whites believe that minorities face a lot of discrimination in Providence. However, 45 percent of African-Americans report minorities encounter a lot of discrimination and 39 percent of Latinos say minorities face a lot of discrimination.

There are differing views about electoral cooperation between African-Americans and Latinos to elect particular candidates. Sixty-two percent of African-Americans feel there should be a lot of cooperation, 59 percent of Latinos feel that way, and 39 percent of whites believe there should be a lot of electoral cooperation.

On issues such as affirmative action and bilingual education, there are substantial differences by group. For example on affirmative action, 46 percent of whites favor affirmative action efforts to hire minority employees, compared to 68 percent of African-Americans and 80 percent of Latinos. Eighty-nine percent of Latinos think Providence public schools should offer bilingual education for those who do not speak English, compared to 57 percent of whites and 76 percent of African-Americans.

In looking at age, education, and income by group, Latinos are the youngest and poorest within the city, and have the lowest educational attainment. For example, while 15 percent of white households make less than $20,000 a year, 34 percent of Latinos and 23 percent of African-Americans earn under $20,000. Latinos also are the group having the highest percentage of first generation families. Twenty-three percent of Latinos say their family has lived in the United States for only one generation, compared to 8 percent of African-Americans and 7 percent of whites who say they have lived here just for one generation.

Acting Mayor John Lombardi's performance is rated excellent or good by 26 percent, while 18 percent say it is only fair, 5 percent rate it poor, and 51 percent are undecided.

For more information, see the report at www.InsidePolitics.org or contact Darrell M. West at (401) 863-1163 or Marion Orr at (401) 863-9436.

Survey Questions and Responses

Note: Responses for the following items are shown for the overall sample and for whether the respondent was white, African-American, or Latino or Hispanic. The mayoral general election question is based on likely voters only.

(506 likely voters only) If the election for mayor of Providence were held today, would you vote for: 1) Democrat David Cicilline 2) Green party Greg Gerritt, 3) Republican Dave Talan, or 4) independent Christopher Young 8) don't know 9) no answer

 

Overall

White

Afr-American

Latino/Hispanic

Cicilline

70%

71%

83%

81%

Gerritt

2

2

7

0

Talan

4

4

0

0

Young

1

1

0

0

Undecided

23

22

10

19

How would you rate the job John Lombardi is doing as mayor of Providence? 1) excellent 2) good 3) only fair 4) poor 8) don't know 9) no answer

 

Overall

White

Afr-American

Latino/Hispanic

Excellent

5%

6%

5%

4%

Good

21

21

27

29

Only Fair

18

16

28

26

Poor

5

7

2

5

Undecided

51

50

38

36

Do you think that African-Americans in Providence have: 1) too little, 2) the right amount, or 3) too much political power? 8) don't know 9) no answer

 

Overall

White

Afr-American

Latino/Hispanic

Too Little

45%

42%

77%

51%

Right Amount

23

28

11

25

Too Much

6

6

2

6

Undecided

26

24

10

18

Do you think that Latinos in Providence have: 1) too little, 2) the right amount, or 3) too much political power? 8) don't know 9) no answer

 

Overall

White

Afr-American

Latino/Hispanic

Too Little

38%

38%

44%

57%

Right Amount

30

31

34

25

Too Much

9

8

14

9

Undecided

23

23

8

9

Do you think that whites in Providence have: 1) too little, 2) the right amount, or 3) too much political power? 8) don't know 9) no answer

 

Overall

White

Afr-American

Latino/Hispanic

Too Little

7%

9%

6%

3%

Right Amount

33

35

27

36

Too Much

40

40

58

50

Undecided

20

16

9

11

Are the opportunities for minorities in Providence: 1) getting worse 2) staying the same or 3) getting better? 8) don't know 9) no answer

 

Overall

White

Afr-American

Latino/Hispanic

Getting Worse

13%

12%

21%

16%

Staying Same

25

25

35

34

Getting Better

42

48

36

42

Undecided

20

15

8

8

In thinking about your local community, do you believe that minorities are: 1) easy or 2) hard to get along with? 8) don't know 9) no answer

 

Overall

White

Afr-American

Latino/Hispanic

Easy

63%

71%

64%

61%

Hard

15

14

22

25

Undecided

22

15

14

14

How much discrimination do minority populations face in Providence: 1) only a little 2) some or 3) a lot? 8) don't know 9) no answer

 

Overall

White

Afr-American

Latino/Hispanic

Only A Little

18%

21%

12%

17%

Some

37

43

37

39

A Lot

27

23

45

39

Undecided

18

13

6

5

How would you feel about having a close relative or family member marry a minority? 1) not favorable 2) somewhat favorable 3) very favorable? 8) don't know 9) no answer

 

Overall

White

Afr-American

Latino/Hispanic

Not Favorable

8%

10%

0%

5%

Somewhat Favorable

27

31

30

22

Very Favorable

48

49

61

64

Undecided

17

10

9

9

At election time, how much cooperation do you think there should be between African-Americans and Latinos to elect particular candidates? 1) a little 2) some or 3) a lot? 8) don't know 9) no answer

 

Overall

White

Afr-American

Latino/Hispanic

A Little

10%

14%

5%

3%

Some

28

32

24

33

A Lot

42

39

62

59

Undecided

20

15

9

5

How much cooperation do you think there should be between African-Americans and Latinos to achieve public policy objectives? 1) a little 2) some 3) a lot? 8) don't know 9) no answer

 

Overall

White

Afr-American

Latino/Hispanic

A Little

9%

14%

0%

3%

Some

26

30

24

28

A Lot

47

45

67

60

Undecided

18

11

9

9

How much cooperation do you think there should be between African-Americans and Latinos to get government jobs for their members? 1) a little 2) some 3) a lot? 8) don't know 9) no answer

 

Overall

White

Afr-American

Latino/Hispanic

A Little

11%

16%

3%

4%

Some

24

28

24

26

A Lot

44

42

68

63

Undecided

21

14

5

7

We would like to know something about the feelings you have toward various groups. Have minorities in Providence ever made you feel angry? 1) rarely 2) sometimes or 3) often? 8) don't know 9) no answer

 

Overall

White

Afr-American

Latino/Hispanic

Rarely

45%

52%

38%

49%

Sometimes

31

33

49

34

Often

8

8

6

10

Undecided

16

7

7

7

Have whites in Providence ever made you feel angry? 1) rarely 2) sometimes or 3) often? 8) don't know 9) no answer

 

Overall

White

Afr-American

Latino/Hispanic

Rarely

31%

34%

25%

38%

Sometimes

41

46

51

37

Often

13

14

18

18

Undecided

15

6

6

7

Have minorities in Providence ever made you feel afraid? 1) rarely 2) sometimes or 3) often? 8) don't know 9) no answer

 

Overall

White

Afr-American

Latino/Hispanic

Rarely

52%

57%

54%

62%

Sometimes

26

31

32

21

Often

6

5

6

11

Undecided

16

7

8

6

Have whites in Providence ever made you feel afraid? 1) rarely 2) sometimes or 3) often? 8) don't know 9) no answer

 

Overall

White

Afr-American

Latino/Hispanic

Rarely

57%

60%

68%

69%

Sometimes

24

29

22

21

Often

3

4

0

5

Undecided

16

7

10

5

The Providence school superintendent recently left to take a job in another city. Do you think the next superintendent of Providence public schools should be: 1) white 2) African-American or 3) Latino? 8) don't know 9) no answer

 

Overall

White

Afr-American

Latino/Hispanic

White

7%

7%

10%

6%

African-American

6

5

21

2

Latino

5

2

2

18

Undecided

82

86

67

74

Do you think the city of Providence should use affirmative action efforts to hire minority employees? 1) yes 2) no 8) don't know 9) no answer

 

Overall

White

Afr-American

Latino/Hispanic

Yes

49%

46%

68%

80%

No

30

44

16

10

Undecided

21

10

16

10

Do you think Providence public schools should offer bilingual education for those who do not speak English? 1) yes 2) no 8) don't know 9) no answer

 

Overall

White

Afr-American

Latino/Hispanic

Yes

59%

57%

76%

89%

No

27

39

19

10

Undecided

14

4

5

1

Do you think the government should offer Spanish-language election ballots for Latinos who do not speak English? 1) yes 2) no 8) don't know 9) no answer

 

Overall

White

Afr-American

Latino/Hispanic

Yes

58%

60%

76%

84%

No

28

38

24

14

Undecided

14

2

0

2

Would you characterize your overall political beliefs as: 1) liberal 2) moderate or 3) conservative? 8) don't know 9) no answer

 

Overall

White

Afr-American

Latino/Hispanic

Liberal

30%

36%

26%

33%

Moderate

33

40

37

27

Conservative

17

16

27

26

Undecided

20

8

10

14

Regardless of how you vote, do you usually consider yourself a: 1) Democrat 2) Independent 3) Republican, or 4) something else? 8) don't know 9) no answer

 

Overall

White

Afr-American

Latino/Hispanic

Dem

44%

47%

65%

52%

Ind

26

35

18

18

Rep

6

8

2

4

Something Else

7

7

8

11

Undecided

17

3

7

15

 

Which of the following age group are you in? 1) 18-24 2) 25-34 3) 35-44 4) 45-54 5) 55-64 6) 65 or older 9) no answer

 

Overall

White

Afr-American

Latino/Hispanic

18-24

15%

12%

27%

31%

25-34

17

17

14

28

35-44

18

18

24

24

45-54

17

22

16

9

55-64

9

12

6

2

65+

12

17

8

3

Undecided

12

2

5

3

Including yourself, how many generations has your family lived in the United States? 1) first generation 2) second 3) third 4) fourth 5) fifth or more 8) don't know 9) no answer

 

Overall

White

Afr-American

Latino/Hispanic

First Generation

10%

7%

8%

23%

Second

12

13

8

22

Third

23

28

23

24

Fourth

12

18

6

10

Fifth or More

27

32

47

16

Undecided

16

2

8

5

What is the latest grade of school you completed: 1) some high school or less 2) high school graduate 3) some college 4) college graduate 5) post-graduate work 8) don't know 9) no answer

 

Overall

White

Afr-American

Latino/Hispanic

Some HS

11%

8%

18%

25%

HS Grad

21

21

29

32

Some College

20

24

31

20

College Grad

19

23

17

15

Post-Grad

16

24

5

6

Undecided

13

0

0

2

Does your annual household income fall within: 1) $0-20,000 2) $20,001-40,000 3) $40,001-60,000 4) $60,001-80,000 5) 80,001-100,000 or 6) over $100,000? 8) don't know 9) no answer

 

Overall

White

Afr-American

Latino/Hispanic

$0-20,000

17%

15%

23%

34%

$20,001-40,000

25

25

36

35

$40,001-60,000

15

19

13

8

$60,001-80,000

8

10

6

4

$80,001-100,000

4

6

0

3

$100,000+

7

11

2

0

Undecided

24

14

20

16